well, such criticism can be productive, for example, when writers of listicles do not provide any personal stories or experience, I will criticize them for that, and when writers use the second person narrative to instruct instead of writing in the first person person, I will criticize. For more on this, your readers can see my https://medium.com/technical-excellence/please-stop-telling-readers-what-to-do-918d7adf128f